Thursday, 19 November 2026

The HORL ROLLER SHARPENER Review

 


Several days ago I was asked to review a Roller knife sharpener from the German company HORL. If you haven't heard of them fear not as I will detail everything you need to know about this product from HORL right here!

Ding dong! The courier!
Three well made (certainly good enough for storage) cardboard (with no visible plastic)  boxes arrived (obviously all packed together in a shipping box). From top to bottom, we have the Horl3 Premium set (seen below)


of two ceramic disks, labelled whetstone fine and whetstone extra fine. The box also contained a very nice leather strop, pretty much the same length as the box itself (approx 25.5cm) and about 50mm wide (fine grained cowhide).
They look used because I've used them!


The next box contains HORL's "dock" which is simply a small footprint stand to place the major components on, so they can sit on your desk without making it look like a laboratory or garage work bench top!

The literature contains a scannable QR code for a link to an instructional video but in my humble opinion, the device operation is self explanatory).


This box contained a small "dock" which enables a nice neat placement of the device upon one's desktop.


The Business End!

Then we have the "guts of the system" (my words not theirs!)
The actual roller device with 2 interchangeable abrasive disks included, a diamond "disk" and a finer ceramic disk" (shown below).



The wood appears to be oak and from their press release material it also appears 
that the wood is kiln dried. 

(Image courtesy of Horl)

The manufacture of this device follows the typical modern German mentality of manufacturing, that is blending traditional looking designs and functionality with modern manufacturing techniques as can bee seen in the following images from their website. Hence Made in Germany is a "quality item"  in many peoples minds.

The wooden oak blocks are CNC milled. Ok is a good choice for stability, strength and long lasting durability.

(Image courtesy of Horl)

Milling the holes for the Neodymium magnets (Image courtesy of Horl)


Tolerances are manually checked (Image courtesy of Horl)



Spray booth operations (Image courtesy of Horl)


Robotic packaging (Image courtesy of Horl)






Ok, how does this roller knife sharpener work?


Essentially there is a cylindrical device (a cylinder of wood) which contains silky smooth a bearing system allowing for the spinning of a grinding plate to rotate at each end of this piece of wood. There are two rubber O-rings 

The rubber o-rings serve to grip against the table or any flat and level surface where one is working.

attached to grooves milled into stainless steel moveable "chuck". Actually it's not a chuck but a twist lock mechanism (Horl call it a "Quick lock") whereby the abrasive disks are inserted, twisted to lock and thus held fast in place. 
Horl's "Quick lock" attachment


Whetstone Fine



Whetstone Extra Fine

One holds the wooden cylinder and moves it backwards and forwards along a knife which is held via neodymium magnets  either at 20 degrees or 15 degrees 
The whole setup (using it on my already re profiled edge of my Extrema Ratio DMP)

to the rotating disk of abrasive. (indicated below by the ink pen).



So good is it?

For kitchen knives it works just fine and as described. We used it at 20 degrees and the bevel it placed upon the steel (X50CrMoVN15) of a Du Cigni (made by FOX knives) cooking knife, model 2C 410 16NG, was even and had a nice finish as there are plenty of abrasives in the Premium set; Diamond, a burr remover; then a "whetstone fine" and a final "whetstone extra fine". No grit ratings are given for any of the abrasives.

 The disk with the cut out grooves must be used carefully, (shown below)



My only negative (and maybe I don't know how to utilise this wheel properly yet) is the above wheel as the grooves for me tend to catch the front end of the knife when dragging the roller towards ones self. So at the tip of the knife, using this roller, I only push it away.

as when one approaches the tip of the knife they should only push the roller forward using this disk and not pull it towards oneself, as the action of pulling it towards oneself (ONLY for this disk), it can catch the the tip of the knife if undue pressure is being applied to the roller in a sideways manner.


What about outdoor knives?

Well this knife sharpener, whilst excellent for kitchen knives because most kitchen knives are of a full flat grind, a geometry which best suits the magnetic knife holder/clamp, many outdoor knives come in such a vast array of geometries and certainly full flat grinds work best with the HORL 3. They will take a little longer to sharpen than any kitchen knife as usually kitchen knives are not hardened to HRC 58 an above.

We also tested two high sabre ground blades, a small folder and a medium sized hunting knife. Both knives used Böhler's N690 cobalt steel and both around HRC60.The medium sized hunting knife (TFK) was held ok by the magnetic clamp, whilst the smaller folder from FKMD (model Predator), was just ok. 

It was possible however to put even bevels at 20 degrees upon both knives. However, compared to the kitchen knife  it took some time to achieve this. I should say the operation is easy and without any hand fatigue. In defence of HORL, they do state this on their company site:


(Excerpt taken from the HORL website)


Therefore my suggestion is that this type of sharpener from HORL I would not use for any outdoor knife which isn't a full flat grind. It cannot be used to sharpen a convex edge, only a straight bevel. 

As a side note, I have entertained ideas though, to use the disks manually for sharpening convex edged knives I own, however as stated, the knife roller itself is NOT suitable for such edge sharpening.


Anyway there is a video coming soon illustrating the device in action. I'll give my summary in the video of where i think this device is positioned amongst the out of doors persons, so stay tuned!


@BushCampingTools










Friday, 13 November 2026

What makes for a good survival knife? What should I be looking for BEFORE I Buy?

 Halfbreed Blades Large Bush Knife IS a SURVIVAL KNIFE I'm going to tell you why.



If we are talking about survival in the wilds as apposed to an urban survival situation, the latter being completely different when it comes to knives (IMHO), then let's look at some useful features in such a product intended for the bush/forest/wilderness. 

In this first part of a case study, I'll be mostly referring to just a handful of knives and to begin with let's look at Halfbreed Blades "LARGE BUSH KNIFE".
The manufacturer says the following:


"...a multipurpose field utility knife, primarily intended for use by extreme outdoor enthusiasts"

Firstly, let's deal with a definition of an "Extreme outdoor entusiast"

What's an "extreme outdoor enthusiast"? I'd say anyone who is not content with following the well walked trails and hiking routes, camping with hundreds of other campers and fishing alongside hundreds of other people fishing. I'm careful not to include hunters here, as by default, which is one of safety, they should be only operating in an environment which is remote from others for safety and common sense. Hence there are laws throughout the world of where guns and bows can actually be discharged and certainly that is not alongside hikers and campers in National parks. 

There are exceptions to this of course and I will only list one which immediately comes to mind and that is/was New Zealand where it is possible to hunt inside of a national park with a firearm.

If one is frequenting the well walked trails and campsites, there is absolutely no reason to be carrying a large knife, ie a knife with a blade over 6". Usually for such campsites, fires are not permitted and thus there is no requirement to chop or baton wood, only to cut up one's meals, if indeed they require such operations. Bringing out a big knife in such scenarios can attract unwanted attention and in some cases alert the ever present Karens, signalling them into action and soon the local ranger has descended upon the campsite and you are getting a talking to (well this depends upon where you are). Unfortunately these days Karens are everywhere because by default Karens are those who have nothing better to do than to ruin someone else's day/time but that's another story subject. However, this is not the reason not to carry a big knife into well frequented campsites and hiking trails. The real reason is common sense not to carry unnecessary equipment with you which in reality will get little if no use on such trips. If one wants to carry a large knife and or hatchet then choose the correct environment for such tools, so they actually get used, that's my advice.

So let's now talk about what kinds of environments can warrant taking a large knife. Any environment away from the general public, so this means generally off track into some wilderness area. It's that easy. Somewhere deserted as in on a deserted island. Sure there are plenty of such places and sure they are remote but knock yourself out they are a hell of lot of fun and this is definitely extreme camping. 

You will have to travel via plane, motorbike, bicycle, walk, boat etc. but accessing such places of wilderness does require a certain amount of savvy in terms of being able to exist independently for a certain amount of time without causing alarm to loved ones and friends and of course not appearing on the 6 O'clock news!

Now that you have that "savvy", which includes the right mental attitude, you can go out an get yourself a BIG KNIFE. But seriously, let's look at why the Halfbreed Blades Large Bush Knife fits the category for "extreme outdoor enthusiast".

Firstly, it must be practical and thus useful in the type of environments I have just described above. So is it? Let's see!
Halfbreed Blades describe this knife as a .......
A field knife, eh?  So is a field knife an survival knife? Or does a survival knife need to have a saw back? Come on are survival knives meant to have a saw back? I mean what is a "field knife"? Ok enough with these questions let me tell you what I think about the design of the  Large Bush Knife.
I like
  • It's built like a tank, in that, I'd be hard pressed to destroy such a knife as K340 is super tough and G10 is pretty much indestructible.
  • It's comfortable to use without gloves.
  • It's got a non slip grip with wet hands due to the strategic milling pattern in the G10 scales.
  • It can hammer wooden pegs into the ground and if need be belt steel spikes into the ground. The blade has some weight to it.
  • It is not handle heavy and this is important to reduce long usage fatigue.
  • K340 ISODUR steel , stays sharp, easy to sharpen, resists chipping, super tough, I mean super tough! (I know I've said it already but you get my point.
  • It has a non rotatable stainless steel cup on both side of the handle and this is a total must for use in the bow drill friction fire technique, one of the easiest of the friction techniques to light a fire without any incendiary materials such as matches, cigarette lighters and or fire steels and natural flints. For the bow and drill friction fire to work a suitable "cup" or top block must be employed and often this is one of the hardest parts to find or to fabricate from natural materials. It must last (preferably) and present the least amount of friction (one doesn't want the embers from this end!).
  • No vicious butt end present to injure the user.
  • holes present to lash the knife to a pole to access out of reach objects (not to make a spear-although it is possible).
  • Gimping in all the right places.

I don't like


I don't like the fact the blade is coated and if one looks after K340 even with a bit of care, "without going over the top" K340 will resist rusting. If the blade was uncoated then it would be totally food safe. The only version of this Large Bush Knife offered in an uncoated steel, is the one made with the more expensive CPM 3V, So I'm saying if other manufacturers can bring out uncoated K340 blades/knives (and I own them), then so can Halfbreed Blades if they want to. Non reflective coatings for maybe staying out of site out of mind, ok but even their knives marked "survival" are coated. Many of my viewers have also commented about the coated blade is not what they like in this blade.
 



If you have to, one can pound away all day long on this beast of a knife with zero ill effect other than that you will be slowly wearing off the blade coating!


 It's entirely possible to cut down small trees with this knife, although the optimal tool is of course an axe or a saw.

North American/European Forest action, no problems! But you will need some stamina on such hardwoods are seen above!

What kinds of environments can this knife work in?
Due to the belly of this knife it can be used for skinning game (although of course it is not a hunting knife). 

What about the tropics?
Easily able to hack down giant bamboo

It is heavy enough to be able to hack into dry or green
 coconuts 




or any of the plethora of vegetables in the tropics. 


Yam's are full of carbs and can be purchased from literally any market all around the globe in tropical regions. They store well, carry well and taste great. Note they MUST be thoroughly cooked BEFORE consuming! I've done a lot of wild camping in the tropics subsisting on nothing but coconuts and coconut water to cook rice and other vegetables and without a hefty knife you are going no where with a coconut LOL.


Peeling a large yam, no problems, the grind works well for peeling of food items. Note, not all blade grinds are suitable for peeling of vegetables and fruits, the only way to check this out is to watch someone who has done it as it is unlikely any shop will allow you to "test drive" this in order to ascertain this information prior to a purchase. Also in order to peel fast maybe a smaller knife is better but some large knives can work although note many don't. SO if you want to use this knife of yours to eat with then you had better make sure you can do exactly that. Personally, when travelling in the tropical regions of the globe I would prefer a knife such as a machete 

with a longer blade but of course this may mean you must also carry it in populated areas. We did do this on bikes and the machete was wrapped in some discarded cardboard so as not to a attract any unwarranted attraction and also as standby weapon if need be.


How about?

Dry desert environments no problems

Since the Large Bush Knife carries some weight to it and the geometry is such that it is easy to chop with, as apposed to one can chop with it, there is a difference here, it can handle chopping and processing dry hardwoods because in the scene you see above there are few trees and the smaller bushes with dead wood are very gnarled and very hard, so a knife must be able to hold an exceptional edge to be of any use in such dry and dusty environments. Most of such wood will be covered in sand and dust and these materials are abrasive, K340 holds a very good edge under such conditions. Smaller knives with little weight are useless in such environments.










































Wednesday, 28 October 2026

New from Extrema Ratio The BFK PIXEL EDC



Extrema Ratio BFK PIXEL Full Review





Extrema Ratio's BFK Pixel  is a small fixed blade knife (but the largest in the PIXEL range) offered in several variations. Here are the basic specifications of the model seen above:

Steel: Listed as "Nitrogen"
Handle scales: (Milled) Green Carbon Fibre
Fixing bolts and fittings: stainless steel- type not listed
Kydex scabbard (standard riveted construction)
Associated nylon type "Paracord" and small plastic cord lock.
2 Malice clip/straps. Material unlisted but looks like some sort of polyurethane?)

Other versions are with Magnacut and or Aluminium scales and or G10 and or micarta.

How does the BFK PIXEL compare to other "neck type" Knives from Extrema Ratio?

From bottom to top: SATRE, VERSA (Expeditions) and BFK PIXEL

Let's discuss the Steel "Nitrogen"

On the practical front, the undesignated "Nitrogen" steel performs really well. I have cut, bashed, sideways dragged, sliced and carved my way through countless natural materials whilst out in the bush. The blade has been hardened to HRC 58 according to the manufacturer and I have never witnessed any sort of indication of corrosion on the satin surface. It is true (as the manufacturer states regarding their "Nitrogen steel"*), a simple strop and the blade remains razor sharp after working on hardwoods, and potentially corrosive food and plant saps/resins. 

How often am I stropping such a blade? Not often at all. In fact the frequency would equate to a weekend camping trip (where cutting food and preparing a fire along with gathering mushrooms and herbs, gutting and cutting up fish (no skinning or butchering ie hunting game) easily up to 2 times per month. So for most, this equates to two weekends away every month. Well that's a lot if you are working a regular weekly job. I'm not going to talk about using this knife in a professional way, ie every day like a chef for example or someone in the fishing industry or hunting game for a living. This is my third knife featuring this undesignated "Nitrogen" steel. So it is certainly not necessary to enjoy the wilds if I do not know what exactly is this nitrogen steel alloy only to know that it performs with good corrosion resistance and does not need to be sharpened the moment I use it.

Blade Finish

Highly polished Satin finish, with the edge hand ground and polished. Just incase you don't know, a polished edge will always hold up against corrosion better than a roughly milled edge regardless of the steel.

If you are one who is concerned about food safe blades, then you can't really go past the satin finish. 



Now for a (brief) Technical discussion

The purposeful addition of nitrogen into modern steel alloys has been shown to increase many favourable properties of the steel especially in terms of fine grain structure. To date, there are several acknowledged nitrogen enhanced alloys used in cutlery manufacture. For example but not limited to: Nitro B; Nitro V; Nitro X7; Vanax (although more widely known for it being a high vanadium content alloy); Sandvik's 14C28N; BD1N; X50CrMoVN15; LC 200N (Cronidur 30); Nitrobe 77; Vancron 40 etc.
This steel, simply labelled "Nitrogen" could be any of the above plus something else. In fact, for 420HC it has been shown that small amounts of Nitrogen introduced into this steel has beneficial results in terms of performance (I am not referring to ion implantation, which merely implants Nitrogen into a nano layer on the exterior of the steel and in the case of 420HC has shown definitely improvements in hardness and wear resistance). As far as nitrogen enhancement is concerned it has long been know that even very small amounts of Nitrogen have had beneficial effects upon tool steel performance (for example see https://www.researchgate.net/publication/26872202_Effect_of_increased_nitrogen_content_on_the_structure_and_properties_of_tool_steels

Whatever the Nitrogen steel alloy they are using is really irrelevant because one can not be biassed as to it's performance based upon the knowledge of what is already known for currently employed nitrogen enhanced tool steels. So from the point of view of such "testers" such as myself, my findings are simply based upon real world performance and not upon a name.

If any of the above worries you and you can simply not own or use a knife where you must know the actual alloy (or at least see some numbers or name engraved upon the blade) then such a knife is not for you. 

Back in the day, many a knife company existed (and still do) just fine with no name brand carbon steels, fact! Nowadays we have convinced ourselves that unless it has the label of "Magna Star" (this is a fictitious name I invented for the next series after MagnaCut) then we simply can not function on the trail let alone in the wilderness LOL! 

Actually, I believe there are many other, than the now infamous "Bark River", who are in fact using steels other than what is laser engraved upon them and simply are yet to be caught out! In most cases many manufacturers add a premium value to their products by way of the steel designation.

Most people (again another fact) would not be able to tell the difference outside of a laboratory environment using at the very least a XRF to analyse the steel constituents of what steel is in their knives.

The Carry System

Like all Extrema Ratio carry systems (I like to say "carry systems" rather than simply call it a scabbard) the BFK Pixel is one of modular in design. It comes with a kydex sheath, which via friction alone securely locks the knife in place. The knife can be thus carried upside down around one's neck via the included paracord loop,

or on a belt via the 2 included Malice straps. There are other optional carry methods such a belt clip (not shown here but you can check it out on their site here.


Shown below is the BFK Pixel set up for lefthand carry in the horizontal postion.



Seen below is the Extrema Ratio BFK Pixel setup for right hand belt carry in the horizontal manner.




At 3.5" or 89mm blade length, the Extrema Ratio BFK PIXEL is totally at home on day hikes where one might chance upon or deliberately look for mushrooms, or lighting a fire for lunch; 
Yes, you are seeing correctly, I have lit a small fire upon a fallen tree which is basically very damp but not as wet at the forest floor.

have the need to cut up one's food for the day, do a spot of fishing or even on a well trodden hiking and camping trail, 
collecting materials for a fire (Or to enable one to sit upon any damp objects as birch bark is waterproof) as seen below.

                    

The BFK Pixel pictured above sitting atop of the Yanagai Matsutake mushroom otherwise known as the Poplar Mushroom, a delicious mushroom which a certain times of the yer can be found growing upon the dead parts of certain poplar varieties. I cut mushrooms for most of the day and came home with a bag an extra 5Kgs heavier after cutting mushrooms against the dirty bark of trees and their roots for most of the day. The knife held an excellent edge after such work.




Geometry of the Blade

The main blade features a gradual curvature, that while subtle, does not go unnoticed, ending in a tanto-esque tip. The grind is that of a high sabre. The spine has a gradual thinning from 3.85mm at the butt end towards the tip at 3.4mm approx 20mm from the tip, so it's clearly not a super thin tip but also thin enough to make this blade function well at any penetrative tasks.


The handle scales are minimal yet provide a totally non slip grip in ungloved hands (this version in milled green carbon fibre).


There is a generous lanyard hole for either a cord or better still some flat "climber's accessory tape".

As with all "neck-type and or EDC fixed blades", some will find if their hands are bigger than size 8.5/9, this type of blade will be simply too small for their paws.
 

On this day hike I only took the BFK PIXEL with me and it wasn't a problem to prepare feather sticks and cut birch bark  for a fire, cut into some birch wood to make a divot to start a small fire, cut up some food and chop a few small branches which were getting in the way of me picking some rather delicious mushrooms. On top of all of this the knife on the day was carried covertly around my neck under my jacket.










From the manufacturer's literature regarding their "Nitrogen" steel.
*Nitrogen is the technical specification of Extrema Ratio: dedicated steel selection, machining and heat treatment cycle.

I don't know about any of this above but from what I do know, it is paramount for Nitrogen enhanced steels, (for example Nitro X7) not to allow the edge to heat up unnecessarily during sharpening processes, maybe that's why they mention "machining" in order to emphasise their attention to details for those in the know. My point is this knife cuts well and stays sharp. 



BCT

@BushCampingTools